Book Review: Montauk by Nicola Harrison @NicolaHAuthor @StMartinsPress #stephlvsbooks #montauk #bookreview #historicalfiction

Book Title and Author: Montauk by Nicola Harrison 
Publication Date and Publisher: June 4, 2019 by St. Martin’s Press
Genre: Historical Fiction
Pages: 400 pages
Buy on
Date Read: May 12, 2019 (e-arc)

4 Stars

Goodreads Synopsis:

Montauk, Long Island, 1938.

A simple town on the brink of a glamorous future.

A marriage drifting apart.

A life on the edge of what is and what could be…

An epic and cinematic novel by debut author Nicola Harrison, Montauk captures the glamour and extravagance of a summer by the sea with the story of a woman torn between the life she chose and the life she desires.

Montauk, Long Island, 1938. 

For three months, this humble fishing village will serve as the playground for New York City’s wealthy elite. Beatrice Bordeaux was looking forward to a summer of reigniting the passion between her and her husband, Harry. Instead, tasked with furthering his investment interest in Montauk as a resort destination, she learns she’ll be spending twelve weeks sequestered with the high society wives at The Montauk Manor—a two-hundred room seaside hotel—while Harry pursues other interests in the city. 

College educated, but raised a modest country girl in Pennsylvania, Bea has never felt fully comfortable among these privileged women, whose days are devoted not to their children but to leisure activities and charities that seemingly benefit no one but themselves. She longs to be a mother herself, as well as a loving wife, but after five years of marriage, she remains childless while Harry is increasingly remote and distracted. Despite lavish parties at the Manor and the Yacht Club, Bea is lost and lonely and befriends the manor’s laundress whose work ethic and family life stir memories of who she once was. 

As she drifts further from the society women and their preoccupations and closer toward Montauk’s natural beauty and community spirit, Bea finds herself drawn to a man nothing like her husband –stoic, plain spoken and enigmatic. Inspiring a strength and courage she had almost forgotten, his presence forces her to face a haunting tragedy of her past and question her future. 

Desperate to embrace moments of happiness, no matter how fleeting, she soon discovers that such moments may be all she has when fates conspire to tear her world apart… 

My Thoughts:

Montauk is more historical romance than it is historical fiction and typically that’s not what I’m looking for when I pick up a historical novel, so I was very pleasantly surprised to be swept away by the utter beauty of Nicola Harrison’s debut novel.

Harrison impressed me from the start with her writing style. It is lyrical and flows so elegantly as she describes the beauty of Montauk, the charming village off the end of Long Island known still today for its gorgeous beaches, luxury resort, and historic lighthouse.

In 1938, Beatrice Bordeaux and husband Harry head to Montauk Manor, the luxury resort built by famous financier Carl Fisher (developer of Miami Beach), with plans that she will spend the summer there with other wealthy wives while he visits from the city on the weekends―although he rarely ever visits as promised. Beatrice loses all hope in reigniting their passion and trying for a child, especially once she discovers Harry has other interests.

Beatrice, who is from a middle-class family, soon grows bored and annoyed with the gossipy, sniping, idle other wives and takes off exploring the seaside village where she befriends Elizabeth, the laundress for the resort. Elizabeth and her family remind Beatrice of her own roots, and she begins to clearly see what she’s missing in her own marriage and life.

Beatrice also becomes close to Thomas, the lighthouse keeper, and the relationship that develops between the two is quite lovely and gives Beatrice a chance to discover the woman she really wants to be. Yet, it’s emotional and bittersweet, and I shed some tears―so maybe keep some tissues handy.

I really enjoyed this one and the issues it explored such as class privileges and societal norms of the time period and true love without money versus living in a loveless marriage. If you like your hist-fic to have a romantic side, then Montauk is just perfect. It’s also an ideal summer read since Harrison does such a wonderful job taking you right to the beach town of Montauk!

**Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for an ARC. All opinions are my own.**

signature (1)





16 thoughts on “Book Review: Montauk by Nicola Harrison @NicolaHAuthor @StMartinsPress #stephlvsbooks #montauk #bookreview #historicalfiction

    1. This was really good and it read less like historical fiction than some other books. It was a light read (sad at the end though) that I think is great for summer. You’re welcome and thank you!


    1. So am I-she did the romance very well in this one though. It’s woven in to the plot isn’t steamy or overdone. I generally won’t read historical romance, but I’m glad I read this one. Thank you, Marialyce!


  1. I wasn’t expecting this one to be more on the romance side, Steph. It sounds really good, though. I have so many June 4 and June reads to get through. Hmmm. Your review is absolutely fabulous and definitely has me wanting to read it at some point. ♥️ xoxoxo


    1. It was more than I expected it to be too but not unpleasantly so. It was well-done and didn’t dominate the book although it was neccesary to the plot of that makes sense? I have a ton of June 11 books to get through, more than I ever should have taken on since we leave for Pawley’s Saturday. Hubby is less than thrilled because that means my face will be buried most of the time in some kind of device trying to stay on top of things. I don’t know what I was thinking (not thinking). Thank you! I hope you can get to it at some point. It really was lovely. xoxo ♥

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Sounds like a solid read for a debut novel, and it’s good that there’s more depth to this (as I find too many that are in or tip towards the romance genre can be too shallow or lacking substance) so it’s interesting it covers wider issues, like social class. Great review as always, Steph! xx

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.